Unpaid but Working: Recognizing Family Caregiving in Medicaid Work Requirements

Back to Resources
ATI – Work
09/10/2025
AUTHOR – ATI Advisory

Unpaid but Working: Recognizing Family Caregiving in Medicaid Work Requirements

By Anne Tumlinson, Michelle Herman Soper, and Tyler Cromer

Imagine being a Medicaid beneficiary working a minimum-wage job, meeting your state’s new work or community engagement requirement. Then your mother falls, breaks her hip, and comes home needing help with bathing, dressing, medications, and meals. You want to prevent her from moving to a nursing home. You reduce your hours to provide care and wonder if you can keep your job at all.

Now, you’ve traded paid for unpaid work. You are still working — just in a way that is not captured by traditional employment measures. Under new Medicaid rules, you could also risk losing health coverage. This is a plausible outcome under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), signed into law in July 2025, which requires certain Medicaid beneficiaries to complete at least 80 hours per month of employment, training, or other activities to maintain coverage. While the law does not appear intended to impose these requirements on family caregivers, the way it is implemented could inadvertently do so if details are not addressed carefully. Unless federal and state regulators act thoughtfully and carefully, unpaid family caregivers — who are already propping up a fragile healthcare system — may find that the implementation of this new law penalizes them for the very work that keeps their loved ones out of costly hospitals and nursing homes.

Defining Caregiving

Section 71119 of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act requires states to implement work and community engagement requirements for adults ages 19 to 64 who are covered through the Affordable Care Act Medicaid expansion or a waiver program that provides minimum essential coverage. Beginning in 2027, these individuals must complete at least 80 hours a month of employment, job training, or other qualifying activity to retain Medicaid coverage. The law provides exemptions for certain individuals, including caregivers of children age 13 and younger and for individuals with disabilities. However, the details of how “caregiver” will be defined and the criteria for documenting and approving exemptions for family caregiving remain open to development and interpretation.

These implementation details will shape whether — and how — unpaid family caregivers are recognized within the policy. These caregivers provide a range of supports, from medication management and help with activities of daily living like bathing and transportation, to help navigating insurance and coordinating care between medical providers. Without this unpaid labor, individuals with serious health needs – including individuals with disabilities as well as older adults, those recovering from injury or illness or who otherwise require support with Activities of Daily Living every single day – are less able to remain at home, increasing demand for higher-cost institutional care.

Demographic trends further underscore the importance of this issue. The Census Bureau projects the 80+ population will grow by over 50 percent, from about 15 million people to over 22 million over the next ten years. This group is more likely than the “younger old” to experience disease and age-related functional decline that require sustained daily support, which is often provided by family caregivers. The attention and labor these care needs demand can push family members out of the paid labor force and the opportunity for employer-sponsored insurance and into unpaid family caregiving and Medicaid eligibility.

While the need for home-based care is increasing, the systems that fund and deliver it remain limited:

  • Medicare does not cover ongoing in-home care, even for those with high levels of need.
  • Medicaid offers home-based services only to individuals who meet strict eligibility criteria, with caps and waitlists common in many states.
  • The paid caregiving workforce faces shortages, low wages, and high turnover.

Without careful design, Medicaid work requirements could unintentionally create coverage risks for people who reduce or leave paid employment to provide needed care — particularly when that care already substitutes for paid services.

Implementation Questions

States with prior experience designing work requirement programs have generally exempted unpaid family caregivers. However, most states that designed these programs in the late 2010s did not implement them, and operationalizing these exemptions under OBBBA will require attention to definitions, documentation processes, and administrative burden.

Questions for federal and state policymakers include:

  • How will “caregiver” be defined to identify eligible caregivers?
  • How will “disabled individual” be defined to identify care recipients for whom eligible caregivers can provide care?
  • How will states ensure caregivers aren’t disenrolled due to administrative complexity or misunderstanding?
  • What type of documentation and systems infrastructure will be required for states to oversee this process, while also reducing unnecessary administrative burdens on caregivers?
  • How will paid caregivers — including those who may work fewer than 80 hours a month — in consumer-directed programs be treated?
  • How can administrative processes minimize burden on caregivers while preserving program integrity?

Moving Forward

Careful program design can support Medicaid policies which reflect the realities of unpaid caregiving and help to maintain coverage for those meeting the spirit of the law and support the sustainability of home-based care.

A clear, well-implemented policy framework can prevent unintended consequences for caregivers, safeguard coverage for those meeting the intent of the law, and support the broader sustainability of home-based care.

Recent Work

Work

State Approaches to TNC Incorporation in Medicaid NEMT

State Medicaid agencies are required to ensure necessary transportation to and from covered medical services for Medicaid beneficiaries. This benefit, known as non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) or the assurance of transportation, has been a required Medicaid benefit since 1966 and was codified in federal statute under the Consolidated Appropriates Act of 2021. State Medicaid agencies must design NEMT programs that support access to care through a range of transportation modalities to meet the diverse needs of beneficiaries, and do so while meeting Medicaid financing, service quality, and program integrity requirements.
Read More Read More
Work

PACE Growth by the Numbers: October 2026

Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) is a capitated health plan that provides comprehensive Medicare and Medicaid covered services to frail, older adults in the community who are eligible for nursing home care. New research from ATI explores the latest enrollment trends and highlights latest opportunities for PACE growth.
Read More Read More
Work

A Practical Option for States: One-Time Medicaid Reassignment to Support D-SNP Alignment

Beginning January 1, 2030, Dual Eligible Special Needs Plan (D-SNP) enrollment must be fully aligned with Medicaid plan enrollment, and beneficiaries will no longer be able to stay in their current D-SNP. Building on a previous ATI resource, this brief outlines a transitional strategy for states subject to the impending D-SNP enrollment alignment requirements to consider.
Read More Read More
See more Work
Share
LinkedIn / /